In addition to Hudson and Taghkanic, whose absentee ballot counts are still pending and likely to go to court, the Columbia County Board of Elections has completed its initial review of absentee ballots in a number of other towns where the election was too close to call on November 8th.
Above are combined results for the Greenport and Hillsdale Supervisor races, based on data tables obtained by Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) requests from the BOE. These appear to show Republican (and former Hudson Alderman) John Porreca as a very narrow winner over Democrat Ed Nabozny for Greenport Super by the narrow margin of just six votes. The reported tally in Hillsdale was less narrow in the end, returning Supervisor Art Baer to office by 51 votes.
However, per the caveat above, all of these numbers are subject to final certification by the BOE, and could change. When an election is as tight as six votes, even the smallest change or error matters.
Word is that the counting of Hudson absentee and affidavit ballots will now occur on Monday, the soonest that Bill Hallenbeck’s attorney Giff Whitbeck is available.
With just 27 votes separating Hallenbeck and his mayoral opponent, Nick Haddad, there are an estimated 220-225 absentee and affidavit ballots to be considered, though 10-20% of those could prove invalid. Ballots for the Hudson race only came out of their impoundment yesterday, with recanvassing of the Hudson results and logging of the poll book information and affidavit ballots taking place yesterday. (The Board of Elections has to first verify the election night results, and also review the books to make sure no one who submitted an absentee ballot also voted on the machine on November 8th.)
Ballots for other close races in Claverack, Greenport, Hillsdale and Taghkanic will likely hit the tables today (Tuesday) and presumably will be complete before Thanksgiving.
The already-slow pace of the counts has been further reduced by the existence of a super-tight judicial race between Republican Catherine “Kiki” Cholakis and Democrat Ray Elliott, with lawyers for each observing counts in every town in a seven-county area.